Will Donald Trump be Impeached?
Whether or not you like Donald Trump, one thing that many of us will agree upon is the notion that the simple fact his potential impeachment is being considered, only a few short months into his presidency, is a stunning turn of events. Still, this is where the bizarre story being written in the White House has brought us.
Last week, Trump abruptly fired F.B.I. Director James Comey. Almost immediately, the White House’s explanation of why Comey was fired began to fragment, as none of President Trump, Press Secretary Sean Spicer, or any of Trump’s handlers – such as Kellyanne Conway – could get their story straight, or even aligned with one another’s.
Fast-forwarding to this week, a leaked memo surfaced in which Mr. Comey detailed his meeting with President Trump. According to the memo, the meeting – which occurred the day after National Security Advisor Mike Flynn’s resignation – centered around the potential investigation of Mr. Flynn’s contact with the Russian ambassador to the United States, both before and following the November 8th Election. During their meeting, Comey writes that Trump said to him, “I hope you can see your way clear to letting this go, to letting Flynn go.” Trump continued, “He is a good guy. I hope you can let this go.” Comey would only go as far as to agree that Flynn was “a good guy”, but wouldn’t commit to dropping any such investigation. Later, Comey was terminated.
Unsurprisingly, the White House has denied the accuracy of the leaked memo. Many analysts and political pundits have pointed out that Trump’s firing of Comey – particularly with this leaked memo coming to light – establishes the very real possibility that Trump could be impeached for Obstruction of Justice (the same threat that forced Richard Nixon to resign his Presidency on August 8, 1974).
Today, it is being reported that the investigation has now identified a “senior White House advisor” who is “close to the president”. Many Democratic politicians, as well as some Republican politicians, are demanding to see the Comey leaked memo. This bipartisan interest in the memo should be worrying for Trump. It certainly appears that the Russia investigation is not going away anytime soon, and their could be major political fallout in the near future.
How Will Markets React if Trump is Impeached?
Markets this week have not taken Comey’s dismissal well, with some major Canadian and US Stock Indices suffering their worst day in over 8 months on Wednesday.
Political uncertainty is bound to weigh on investor confidence. Trump is a wildcard, prone to saying and doing what he wants, regardless of truth or accuracy (or legality), and the potential risks associated with such a personality as president are being felt right now. However, Trump’s potential successor would be far less risky, from a pro-business point of view.
Should Trump be impeached and removed from office, in would step Vice-President Mike Pence to assume the role of Commander-In-Chief. The initial uncertainty of an impeachment could result in a drop in the market; however, the market’s long-term response would likely be positive. There are three key reasons for this:
Firstly, Pence is obviously a Republican. He served as Governor of Indiana from 2013-2017, and shares the same pro-business views as his Republican counterparts. He is, relative to Trump, a drama-free. He knows and has a good working relationship with many politicians in both the House and the Senate. His time as Governor has given him both the experience and the knowledge of the political process.
Secondly, at least until the 2018 Midterm Elections, both the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate are controlled by the Republicans, as they hold majorities in both. Tax reform may be put to the backburner temporarily if impeachment proceedings happen, but at some point, the Republicans should be able to start advancing their political agenda.
Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, Pence’s relative stability would allow the markets to rebound in a less politically risky environment. It would be (pro) business as usual.
What Action Should I Take?
Our recommendation, as always, is to continue to focus on the long-term picture. A reactionary selloff if the markets drop in the near-term could result in missing out on the inevitable rebound. When that train leaves the station, you don’t want to be left standing on the platform waiting to purchase a ticket.
In fact, investors should look at a potential short-term market drop as a great opportunity to invest, as the potential to reap a nice return will present itself to those who are paying attention.
Should you have any questions or concerns, we are happy to discuss them with you. Please feel free to give us a call or send us an email.
In the short-term, enjoy your May long weekend!
Sources: CNN Politics, The Globe and Mail, The New York Times, The Washington Post